Bradbury Owns that Name
reply
Posted by Skipster (Skipster@msc-inc.net) on June 22, 2004 8:30 AM
Well, Ray Bradbury is famous for that name style. It is an obvious rip off of a copyrighted name and if Bradbury wasn't compensated or permission was not granted, Bradbury is right! The arrogance of Moore is abhorrent.
RE: Bradbury Owns that Name
reply
Posted by Charley (charley@dtheatre.com) on June 22, 2004 11:01 AM
The Associated Press Briefing on Media law states that, "to determine whether a particular use [of copyrighted material] is fair, courts are required to evealuate [1]the purpose of the use; [2] the nature of the copyright work that is used; [3]the amount and substantiality of the portion used in relation to the work as a whole; and [4] the effect of the use on the potential value of the copyright work."
Bradbury owns the name Fahrenheit 451, not the word "fahrenheit" or that word followed by a number. Moore's intent is clearly to draw a comparison between the world of Bradbury's book, where information is destroyed to keep the people dumb, and our own world, where information is destroyed to keep the people dumb. A comparison is not, technically speaking, a copyright infringement. He has not stolen Bradbury's title if it is the recognition of that title which was the original point.
But with the right controlling the house, senate, executive branch, most lower courts, and the supreme court, Moore might be facing a real problem here.
Moore Is Such a Hypocrite
reply
Posted by A random shemp (No Email) on June 22, 2004 1:51 PM
It's one thing to use a name without the intent of infringing on anybody's ideas, but quite another when you knowingly do it. I already had little respect for Moore, but now I really don't like him. The only legitimate reason I can see for why he wouldn't change the name is to make more money?! Isn't money the motive he's accusing all these politicians of having??
RE: Moore Is Such a Hypocrite
reply
Posted by A random shemp (No Email) on June 22, 2004 5:51 PM
he doesn't want to change the title because the word farenheit is a comparison of ray bradbury's work. is has nothing to do with money. if he changes the title, then his point is lost!
RE: Moore Is Such a Hypocrite
reply
Posted by Charley (charley@dtheatre.com) on June 22, 2004 7:26 PM
Someone (me) pointed out earlier that Moore is clearly not channeling Bradbury just because "fahrenheit" sounds cool. He is referencing that story for a very specific reason.
Also, Moore is against corporate corruption, which stems from greed, but he has never come out against the pursuit of money.
Obligatory rebuttal (I'll do it for you): "Stealing Bradbury's title is just as bad as corporate corruption!"
Answer: See above.
RE: Moore Is Such a Hypocrite
reply
Posted by Skulllfire (Pocko@Argentina.org) on June 24, 2004 7:17 AM
I agree with Molar-Fag: The casting for the
FANTASTIC FOUR IS:
Ed Harris: Mr. Stretcy crotch
Paul Walker: Jon Jon Storm
Russ Crowe: Thing
Milano, Alyssa: Invisible Bi-Hooker
Doom: Henry Winkler
Sometimes when I'm alone I like to fondle my pet monkey's testicles...there is nada wrong with that, is there?
RE: Moore Is A God!
reply
Posted by Ben Affleck's Vagina (Awfulflix@Beantown.org) on June 24, 2004 12:05 PM
Moore has the guts, the nerve, and what's more the guts, to fight corporate America, and it's not too bright Prez. If only there were more men like him, guys like Matt Damon and I would be a lot happier!
Bradbury should get over himself, and give Moore a break, it's not that big a deal!
Copyright, copywrite, copy-fight.
reply
Posted by A random shemp (No Email) on June 27, 2004 3:05 AM
Well this is just a bunch of ..... well ..... pooh. Nobody sued anybody when The Terminator became Terminator II or Terminator III now did they? Maybe Ray needs some Valium ........ or Viagra ........ or both.
RE: Well...
reply
Posted by A random shemp (No Email) on June 27, 2004 10:45 PM
I went to moorelies.com. Now there's a republican website if I've ever seen one. "Moore lies, trust us, buy a bumper sticker, and send a donation. Saw the movie. Loved it. It did not change my mind at all. I, like the majority off the United States did four years ago, will be voting against Bush. AGAIN!!!!