From: (No Email available)

Date: 2005-11-02 09:55:29

Comment:

As a life-long Superman fan and also a huge fan of the Smallville series, I want to give the bottom line. Christopher Reeve was the greatest Superman to date. Better than George Reeves, better than Dean Cain, and better than any other man that has ever put on the costume. He made it real for a whole generation of viewers. But, it is a new generation. Were the costumes in the X-Men movies true to the comics? Hell no! Were they good movies? Hell yeah! I personally have no problem with Brandon Routh or the costume. It seems to fit him and he definitely fits the role well. I believe that you are doing the movie and Mr. Routh a disservice by constantly trying to compare him with Christopher Reeve, especially before the movie has even been shown on the big screen. By the way, Tom Welling would have also been an excellent choice as Superman. Different, than Reeve and Routh, but good nonetheless.