From: (No Email available)

Date: 2005-01-31 04:27:46

Comment:

some films are shot "open frame" at a ratio of 1.33 to 1 (same as a tv set) and are matted in the movie theatre by the projectors apature gate to 1.85 to 1 ratio. this is to preserve the directors original intent. on "open frame" films the video release can show the extra material at the top and bottom of the screen without resorting to "pan and scan" (this additonal picture often includes sound booms and unfinished bits of sets) so this lawsuit settlement is SERIOUSLY IN ERROR as MGM CORRECTLY state on the discs that the widescreen bars preserve the original theatrical format (of films shot "open frame" that is. )

Im a theatre projectionist so trust me, theres nothing wrong with any of the DVDs on this list.all thats been cut out is empty space above peoples heads and unimportant stuff at the bottom

Whats staggering is some of the films on this list were shot "hard matted" (ie the black borders are exposed onto the negative) at 1.85 ratio and ARE CORRECTLY presented as such by MGM
and its sheer stupidity that theyre even on the list in the first place.

I cannot believe that the judges in this instance have a very inept understanding of the difference between "open " and "hard Mattes" or correct theatrical ratios.

im sure the lawsuit could easilly be overturned by any testimony from a film director,cameraman, projectionist etc etc