From: (No Email available)

Date: 2004-11-08 07:39:04

Comment:

There's few reason why the fans one is better and few why you can obviously the fan made one has very little effert put into it. One, everything below anakin is is just totally done in photoshop. what's worst is you can see where it's cut off at.  There's no shine on the rest of the deck, like there is where anakin stands.  Darth Vader's reflexion is too short for compairence to anakin 's height, the lighting and the type of set.  The good side of it is you can easily tell that's there's a relationship between the reflexion with how it connects up threw the black of the outfits to younger man. There's also pretty overall wonderful picture handsome older  Anakin. wahoo...not like everyone cares but some people like seeing the whole picture of him and it's back farer so can't quite see so much of what he looks like.  Since you see him like that psychology people can "relate" to the character more. Plus this picture follows "the rules of thirds" a bit more but not by much.  The picture is in center but it's close to top most line. Although it's kind of plan simple it doesn't have any intensity nor conveny a sense of emotion the official one does.
Reason why the first poster was given that style and look, is simple.  close ups.  It gives you more intensity, relation and emotion from the characters to a audience. The picture tells the story and really tells the about the darker tone of it.  Which lucas said the 3 movie was going to, "the darkest of star wars movies".
The dark figure is following more of the rule thirds kind-of-sort in the same way the fan made one is.  What doesn't work is Anakin's face being cut off. X_x bad bad bad.... bold but bad. If this was perhaps a wider poster the characters shown pushed to left and an ray of the other character in the that set of mood and style I could this really work a lot more like how fan poster is for some. why? well, then it would be more dyamtic then the rather plan, simple and quiet fan poster.  
lol, You can tell I like the official post really....  I like darker tone and I like of anakin there. XD Plus the scar just really works for me.   Overall the official poster totally sets me into the mood of the movie a lot more then fan one.  But hey, that's me and not everyone else's opinion.
---Pardon me I kind want to say this towards the people who don't repect anothers right to their opinion.  What I don't understand is why some people can't handle others opinions and have to "dis" on others.  Then oh my god! Some of "dis" is witty! wahoo!  yeah sure whatever... big man, sure doesn't tell a lot about you.  I hope you girlfriend dumps you after she realize how much you don't repect her opinion ether. *pif*   when people do that whole "dis'in-thing" they certainly are very constructive about it.  They reply, thinking it's in there defence, but really such things just make ya look like you being stubborn and immmature.  oh, then they susposely "uncaring" about what other people think... what I don't under is if don't care why do they reply towards it?   Then these negetive immature people think of themself as good people and even honorable. O_o then umm... why they negative towards others opinions?   I mean if there going to make negetive comments then perhaps use a little less generializing and bandwagoning. Plus, understanding more of where the other person's is coming with their opinion before you starting argueing with them wouldn't hurt ether.  Maybe then a wouldn't be taken as fool then someone "shoves-it-in-your-face."   Okay, I repeat that for only people on here that don't seem to repect other peoples opinion or just have one hell of immature one. *rolls eyes*

....anyway, I don't think the frist movie sucked all that much other wise it wouldn't have gotten a big of fanfair as it did. although I'm pretty sad Lucas lost the "used-gallaxy" look that he talked about him making in the other trilogy. Not like that acting was too much different, Hamill and Hayden don't differ that much.... sorry.  I mean at least Lucas got what he was looking for the characters.    lol, I'm fan of hamill to.. Seaquest, Wing commander and Gyver. wahoo.